Click to return to Tamworth Borough Council

Agenda item

Question Time:

(i)                 To answer questions from members of the public pursuant to Procedure Rule No. 10.


(ii)               To answer questions from members of the Council pursuant to Procedure Rule No. 11



The Mayor Councillor R Kingstone


“Before we deal with the first part of question time, which is questions from members of the public I would just like to make a statement. In my interpretation of the Constitution it is fairly vague with regard to members of the public who submit questions and are not present.  The spirit of the constitution is that if you’re a little bit nervous, a little bit scared about reading out question, if you’re taken ill or incapable of getting to the meeting then yes it is fine for the Mayor to read out your question. However, I think we need to be careful about setting an unwritten precedence where by questions can be submitted by members of the public with the expectation that the Mayor will read them out should  a reasonable excuse, like the examples I’ve stated, not be given. My fear is that we are going to end up with 700 odd questions every meeting from members of the public and no one present to put them.  We could potentially turn into the letters page of the Tamworth Herald rather than a Council meeting. So we will permit these questions this evening but I want us to be cautious about the reasons why people cannot be present. There are often very valid reasons and that’s why we are taking these tonight but let us be cautious as to why the questioner is not present.”


Question read out by Mayor R Kingstone




Under Procedure Rule No 10, Mr Huw Loxton, of Tamworth will ask the Portfolio Holder for Culture and Operational Services, Councillor John Chesworth, the following question:-


“I think we would all agree that the revamp of the castle ground toilets is extremely welcome.  I was under the impression that the toilets would be available at all times, however after making enquiries I am told that they are controlled remotely to ensure availability meets demand and this will be monitored.  There are no fixed opening hours but they will be open into the evening.  Could you tell me exactly how this will work, for example, if they are deemed not necessary after 7pm, but there is an event, could they then be reopened to meet that particular demand?”


Councillor J Chesworth gave the following reply:-


“To save time and for the benefit of everyone I have Mr Loxton’s contact details I will send him the written answer, and will provide a copy of the answers for the minutes and for all members benefit if that’s acceptable”


The Mayor Councillor R Kingstone


“Councillor Chesworth I’m sorry to have to ask you but I want to try and avoid members giving written responses. Do you think it’s possible given that as members of the public are present tonight can we hear the response that you are likely to give?”


Councillor J Chesworth gave the following reply:-


“Absolutely Mr Mayor, no problem.


All of the toilets are fitted with remote time controls with the exception of the Changing Places Facility which is controlled by means of a code which can be obtained by contacting the CCTV service. The five remaining toilets are split into two groups. Three of the toilets operate restricted hours. The other two toilets are open 24 hours a day at present; however this will be monitored and may change if having the facility open at all times leads to excessive vandalism or anti-social behaviour.


There has always been the opportunity to have the public conveniences open and available during events and this hasn’t changed with the provision of the new toilets. Requirements for opening during events would be managed through the event planning process.”



Question read out by Mayor R Kingstone





Under Procedure Rule No 10, Mr Huw Loxton, of Tamworth will ask the Portfolio Holder for Culture and Operational Services, Councillor John Chesworth, the following question:-


“As some of you will know the changing places facility is a particular welcome addition to my family, and of course to many people in our town and visitors.  To gain access to this facility people ring the out of hours street scene number which is available 24 hours a day which is good.  That said, does this mean only those with a working phone can access this facility, and what about those unable to use a phone, for example, is a text service available for those with hearing loss or difficulties?”


Councillor J Chesworth gave the following reply:-


“The Changing Places facility is not currently open for use 24 hours a day and operates restricted hours due to the need to properly maintain it and to limit vandalism and anti-social behaviour. Unfortunately, access does require the user to make contact with CCTV control room by telephone and as such they would need access to a telephone. The nature of the facility is such that it is designed for people with severe physical disabilities and as such they would need to be accompanied by a carer in order to safely use the equipment that has been installed


One of the two toilets that is open 24 hours a day is fully Part M compliant for use by people with physical disabilities. There is no need for contact to be made with anyone in order to access this facility.”




Under Procedure Rule No 11, Councillor P Standen will ask the Leader of the Council, Councillor D Cook, the following question:-


“At last year’s July council I submitted a question asking the Leader of the Council to provide an update on the responses to the letters sent to our neighbouring authorities regarding potential developments on Tamworth's borders?

Could the Leader of the Council please update members as to the current status and what has been achieved in the last year and quarter?”


Councillor D Cook gave the following reply:-


“Thank you Mr Mayor and thank you Councillor Standen for your question.


Building on ours borders without the correct mitigations remains a massive concern for all of us cross party and for the authority itself.


In my answer to you last July I referenced I was meeting with Kit Malthouse, the Minister for Housing in the Home Office building on 18th July 2018. Myself and Mr Barratt (CEO) had this meeting and were successful in getting the Minister to understand the problem we face. What has been more difficult is finding a single fit solution.


I also stated I had sat down with the Leader of Staffordshire County Council to discuss the production of an overarching study on Infrastructure needs vs. new developments. I have had many meeting with him since on the matter and I can confirm we were given a first draft on Thursday 5th September 2019 while at a meeting in Stafford of all Leaders in Staffordshire. The document is so big I cannot E-mail, so we only have one hard copy at present but will fix that ASAP. It has been called the SIP (Strategic Infrastructure Plan).


The document provides a good evidence base for all Councils locally to use in preparation of Local Plans and using at planning committees when making judgements. While the document does not have a legal foothold as such, the evidence within could well do. We are now challenging both SCC and Warwickshire County Council in how it aligns cross border, as the bigger long-term problem is to the East in Warwickshire.


We continue to monitor all progress on developments on our border and I can confirm that the new Assistant Director of Regeneration has been left in no doubt of my feelings on this matter.”


Councillor P Standen asked the following supplementary question


“I hope it feeds in to what you’ve just said, can I thank the leader for his response and could he state what concrete resource people of Tamworth can expect to see within the next six – twelve month’s time frame”


Councillor D Cook gave the following reply:-


“Thank you Mr Mayor if I get my way there will be no concrete going down anywhere on our borders


I think it’s a complicated problem I think we all understand how the Local Plan process actually functions. Do Councils actually build houses these days? In the main, no, willing land owners do.


What we’ve got around Tamworth is a fundamental opportunity and problem at the same time. Land values in and around Tamworth vs what it costs to develop are very advantageous to developers, Tamworth is a very popular place to settle, it’s a very growing place still. What we need are the mitigations, we need to understand what happens when a new housing development pops up on our borders and how it affects our infrastructure, whether that be doctors surgeries, roads, everything involved in the infrastructure provision.


Can I sit here and guarantee no developments will pop up in the next ten years, one year, twenty years, no I cannot, what I can guarantee this Council and I hope cross party will continue to fight to ensure that every development has the correct mitigations that the residents of Tamworth deserve and I hope that remains a cross party commitment. Thank you Mr Mayor”